The EV Naysayers

Mirak

Banned
Banned
Joined
Oct 8, 2020
Threads
111
Messages
3,754
Reaction score
6,166
Location
Kansas
Vehicles
"Sonic" 2021 MME Grabber Blue First Edition
Country flag
I think alot of "truthtellers" (including some of the people who have EVs) like to say that people who enjoy their EV are trying to push it on the masses whom aren't ready for EVs. I don't know if that's true all the time, but as you said you can't force someone to do something. We are transitioning to EVs. Just bc a good percentage the US pop doesn't want or aren't ready for EVs at this point in time doesn't mean that it'll always be that way. So being a "truthteller" at this point is kind of easy if you leave out of the part about this being a transition...and that there are ups and downs during transitions......and that major technology transitions don't happen overnight.
This is my point. Ten years from now all the trade offs we are debating become moot. It just seems like some people want to force the issue now, and I don’t understand why. If you love your EV with its current constraints, great! It’s ok that most Americans aren’t interested yet. That isn’t because of bots or brainwashing.
 

AhardFSU

Well-Known Member
First Name
Antonio
Joined
Apr 10, 2022
Threads
3
Messages
777
Reaction score
730
Location
Riverview
Vehicles
2022 Mustang Mach E
Country flag
This is my point. Ten years from now all the trade offs we are debating become moot. It just seems like some people want to force the issue now, and I don’t understand why. If you love your EV with its current constraints, great! It’s ok that most Americans aren’t interested yet. That isn’t because of bots or brainwashing.
Correct and we agree in part. Where we maybe disagree, is that the amount of people trying to "force" other people into getting an EV is not that large. I'm not referring to mandates on automakers by certain state governments. I'm thinking more along the lines of roving bands of people walking around yelling at others to get an EV. I'm envisioning scenes from The Walking Dead ? .
 

mattyhillnepp

Well-Known Member
First Name
Matt
Joined
Nov 4, 2023
Threads
0
Messages
58
Reaction score
169
Location
Iowa, USA
Vehicles
2023 Mach-e Premium AWD Extended Range
Country flag
There are millions and millions of Americans that don't care who drives an EV. The problems start when you or politicians tell them they have to drive an EV also.
I think finding the root cause as to why people don’t care to drive EVs is the kicker.

Millions of people have been told that EVs won’t work for them when in reality they will.

A few months back I was visiting a customer and he mentioned he just got a new Jeep. Asked if they got the plug-in hybrid, “we don’t have the infrastructure for that here”

Meanwhile I had driven to their location 100% on electricity in my own PHEV Jeep.

It is important to be honest about the inconveniences of EVs, but it is also important to be rational about them.
Will EVs work for people who tow an across the country, probably not, but most people don’t even use their trucks to haul stuff 10 miles from Home Depot to their home.

My husband was a huge “idk about charging on a road trip, that seems like a lot of time wasted” but in reality we are usually stopping every 200-250 miles for something.
When we road trip we take our dogs, usually it takes at LEAST 15 min to get them to potty, convince them it’s time to drink some water, etc. then we have our own bio needs.
Even if we’re eating sandwiches out of a cooler it takes some time to get those together, eat, and then get rid of the garbage

Way too many people have been convinced that EVs won’t work for them and they genuinely do.

Heck my neighbor’s lawn guy drives a f150 lightning and he tows his electric lawn mower around town every day in the summer with it.
 

Vulnox

Well-Known Member
Joined
Nov 12, 2021
Threads
9
Messages
1,087
Reaction score
1,802
Location
Livonia, MI
Vehicles
2024 F-150 Lightning Platinum, 2025 Mach-E Premium AWD ER
Country flag
This is my point. Ten years from now all the trade offs we are debating become moot. It just seems like some people want to force the issue now, and I don’t understand why. If you love your EV with its current constraints, great! It’s ok that most Americans aren’t interested yet. That isn’t because of bots or brainwashing.
Who are these people that want to force the issue now, in terms of pushing everyone to adopt EVs NOW and not in 10 years? While it's a bit variable, even the sales restriction timelines discussed are 2030 in some, 2035 in most newer versions I have seen, so 11 years down the road. And that is just cutoff for new ICE sales (assuming it doesn't change which it can and likely will), I haven't looked into every version but haven't heard of used vehicle sales being stopped, and existing ICE vehicles can continue on the roads. With a life of 10 years or so on most new vehicles sold, that pushes things to 2040-2045 before something like a "real" restriction would take hold as even the used market gets tighter.

I, personally, haven't yet said everyone can convert today, quite the contrary. We have a long way to go on that front. There will always be fringe groups on any topic, making them the focus of your entire platform is what leads to confusion when discussing the actual pros/cons.
 


ctenidae

Well-Known Member
First Name
Alex
Joined
Jan 19, 2022
Threads
37
Messages
1,403
Reaction score
1,852
Location
Stamford, CT
Vehicles
DMG GT; Taycan, Q7, Sienna Hybrid
Occupation
Solver of problems
Country flag
There are a lot more people crying "Don't force me" than there are people trying to do anything close to forcing.

Please, don't let the deep state enable some shifts that provide long term benefits while giving short term joy, every time you mash that pedal.
 

Vulnox

Well-Known Member
Joined
Nov 12, 2021
Threads
9
Messages
1,087
Reaction score
1,802
Location
Livonia, MI
Vehicles
2024 F-150 Lightning Platinum, 2025 Mach-E Premium AWD ER
Country flag
There are a lot more people crying "Don't force me" than there are people trying to do anything close to forcing.

Please, don't let the deep state enable some shifts that provide long term benefits while giving short term joy, every time you mash that pedal.
Exactly, and when someone uses the proposed ICE cutoff mandates I immediately take them at least a little less seriously because any semi-aware adult has to have seen that with almost any mandate there are exemptions. I can make pretty strong predictions on what they will be for the 2035 cutoffs too, and they will be similar to current EPA regulations on fuel economy. You can about guarantee that 3/4 ton and up pickups will keep being sold, as will the rolling chassis based on them used for stuff like RVs and specialized vehicles. Probably a lot of commercial exemptions in general depending where the tech stands at that point.

The focus will be on light duty usage, and whether it even happens on the proposed timelines will depend on infrastructure and capacity to produce the vehicles in appropriate numbers at that point.

The dates proposed aren't for "us" to use as benchmarks against the tech as it is in 2023, they are guidelines for automakers and local governments to start putting those things in motion as we all know it takes time. Can see it in the DCFC install time from the recent infrastructure investments. If things aren't in place no state or local government in the US is going to just completely kneecap their state by just cutting off ICE vehicles at that time. But if they waited until 2034 to say 2035 would be the cutoff, that would be dumb beyond words.
 

Mirak

Banned
Banned
Joined
Oct 8, 2020
Threads
111
Messages
3,754
Reaction score
6,166
Location
Kansas
Vehicles
"Sonic" 2021 MME Grabber Blue First Edition
Country flag
Who are these people that want to force the issue now, in terms of pushing everyone to adopt EVs NOW and not in 10 years? While it's a bit variable, even the sales restriction timelines discussed are 2030 in some, 2035 in most newer versions I have seen, so 11 years down the road. And that is just cutoff for new ICE sales (assuming it doesn't change which it can and likely will), I haven't looked into every version but haven't heard of used vehicle sales being stopped, and existing ICE vehicles can continue on the roads. With a life of 10 years or so on most new vehicles sold, that pushes things to 2040-2045 before something like a "real" restriction would take hold as even the used market gets tighter.
I’m not going to call anyone out by name, but there is plenty of “take your medicine” sentiment peppered throughout this thread, and on the first page alone. People who blame Americans’ slow adoption of EVs on “misinformation” rather than real shortcomings of the current technology. This is the “ramming” I speak of - claiming most Americans are “misinformed” because they’re not interested in EVs yet. I find condescension and tribalism annoying.

One size does not fit all. The current shortcomings are real. They are likely to be moot in another ten years. These are the only points I’ve been trying to make.
 

Vulnox

Well-Known Member
Joined
Nov 12, 2021
Threads
9
Messages
1,087
Reaction score
1,802
Location
Livonia, MI
Vehicles
2024 F-150 Lightning Platinum, 2025 Mach-E Premium AWD ER
Country flag
I’m not going to call anyone out by name, but there is plenty of “take your medicine” sentiment peppered throughout this thread, and on the first page alone. People who blame Americans’ slow adoption of EVs on “misinformation” rather than real shortcomings of the current technology. This is the “ramming” I speak of - claiming most Americans are “misinformed” because they’re not interested in EVs yet. I find condescension and tribalism annoying.

One size does not fit all. The current shortcomings are real. They are likely to be moot in another ten years. These are the only points I’ve been trying to make.
Ah gotcha, yeah that's fair. We would already be a two BEV household if it wasn't for the shortcomings you are referring to, and I would say we are pretty big proponents of BEVs in general. When it came time to get my '23 F-150, it would have been a Lightning of not for the price hikes, Ford's weird content choices (like requiring a Platinum to get B&O Unleashed and power running boards), and the still pretty tame charging curve for such a large battery vehicle.

My hope is Gen 2 Lightning resolves those things and maybe gets it to bump up against 400 miles of range EPA. But if they couldn't get us to buy in, when we are already pretty close to fully sold on the concept, I can totally see why many aren't ready, especially single vehicle homes.
 

KevinS

Well-Known Member
Joined
Oct 11, 2021
Threads
34
Messages
1,515
Reaction score
2,831
Location
Maryland
Vehicles
2021 Mach-E (sold), 2023 Ioniq 6 SEL
Country flag
The way it "works" here, is all those buses ride around empty, or with 1-2 passengers.
That's because there was such a strong message during formative Boomer/GenX culture that implied that if you were riding in a bus it meant you were poor.

My nephews, both in their 20's, always take mass transit and love not using cars. There's definitely been a generational change in the relationship with cars.

For me, cars always implied freedom; for them, it's cost and maintenance. I don't think it's necessarily a bad change.
 

shutterbug

Well-Known Member
First Name
Joseph
Joined
Nov 5, 2020
Threads
13
Messages
1,323
Reaction score
1,810
Location
AZ
Vehicles
MME GB FE—Dead. F150L Lariat SR. 2024 MME Rally
Country flag
That's because there was such a strong message during formative Boomer/GenX culture that implied that if you were riding in a bus it meant you were poor.

My nephews, both in their 20's, always take mass transit and love not using cars. There's definitely been a generational change in the relationship with cars.

For me, cars always implied freedom; for them, it's cost and maintenance. I don't think it's necessarily a bad change.
That, or the buses don't go where they are actually needed. Or they take too long. According to google maps. there is no way to use the bus to get to my last 3 jobs. One job that I could use the bus, would take 24 min by car and 90 min by bus. Adding over 2 hours to daily commute doesn't sound like something I would learn to love.
 

Mach1E

Well-Known Member
Joined
Sep 5, 2021
Threads
93
Messages
10,508
Reaction score
13,293
Location
Florida
Vehicles
69 Mach 1, 11 GT, 21 GTPE- sold, 24 Taycan 4S, 20 F type R
Country flag
Setting aside most of the detractor arguments which are based largely on "what-ifs" and "whatabouts", it seems that most BEV owners that take the dive are satisfied. I believe this is the strongest indicator that while someone can say "well what about when they leave the city?" as if it's a death sentence, clearly most owners are finding it totally doable and it isn't a negative that overcomes their overall ownership experience.

https://www.jdpower.com/business/pr...ectric-vehicle-experience-evx-ownership-study

Above is the 2022 Survey, useful because when you look at the 2023 survey:
https://www.jdpower.com/business/pr...ectric-vehicle-experience-evx-ownership-study

Practically every metric for positive experience has improved.

If these BEVs were really so hard to live with, this bubble would have burst long ago. Again, there are certainly issues, especially around DCFC reliability and upfront cost. But it at least appears that for most owners these aren't hitting them too hard, which so far matches our BEV experience. We haven't had trouble charging at EA stations on our couple road trips and our up front cost was in line with the ICE equivalent vehicle we were considering.

Before someone takes what I said and twists it right around, this is NOT me saying that nobody experiences EA issues, or lines, or whatever. More an indicator that maybe your own "bubble" of experience doesn't always translate into everyone elses.
I love my car.

But it is the “what ifs and what abouts” that will completely prevent mass adoption.

EVERY car is a compromise.

The questions are what compromises you’re willing to live with and which ones you’ll give up.

The most important things for a lot of people though are th the car-
Gets you where you need to go, in a timely manner that you can afford.

And unfortunately that’s where the BEVs have to compromise.

$$ will be a factor for anyone buying a car (yes even the richest people negotiate on car price and look for comparative value).

Getting you where you need to go quickly- that’s a huge deal.

A couple months ago I had to drive 4 hours across the state and then back the next day for a meeting. It started at noon, I carpooled with 2 other people.

Zero chance any of us wanted to take my car.

The good news though is that PHEV pretty much covers all the “what if” use cases. (Long distance, live in apartment/condo, tow something, work vehicles, large family, rural areas, evacuations from Hurricanes, power outages etc).

With current tech, we absolutely cannot hit 100% adoption. So that shouldn’t be the target. And infrastructure wise? I don’t think it’s attainable/affordable anyways.
 

Mirak

Banned
Banned
Joined
Oct 8, 2020
Threads
111
Messages
3,754
Reaction score
6,166
Location
Kansas
Vehicles
"Sonic" 2021 MME Grabber Blue First Edition
Country flag
A couple months ago I had to drive 4 hours across the state and then back the next day for a meeting. It started at noon, I carpooled with 2 other people.

Zero chance any of us wanted to take my car.
Did you try explaining to them that it is actually better to stop twice for 30-40 minutes each way, stretch your legs, and get a few meals? You could have taught them how to use plugshare to research working chargers in advance. People are never gonna adopt if we don’t correct the misinformation and change their way of thinking!!!
 

Mach1E

Well-Known Member
Joined
Sep 5, 2021
Threads
93
Messages
10,508
Reaction score
13,293
Location
Florida
Vehicles
69 Mach 1, 11 GT, 21 GTPE- sold, 24 Taycan 4S, 20 F type R
Country flag
Did you try explaining to them that it is actually better to stop twice for 30-40 minutes each way, stretch your legs, and get a few meals? You could have taught them how to use plugshare to research working chargers in advance. People are never gonna adopt if we don’t correct the misinformation and change their way of thinking!!!
Heck no, because I didn’t want to wake up an hour earlier either

Nor did I want to find an available charger on alligator alley in the Everglades (good luck) nor take the chance that one wouldn’t be available and miss our business meeting.

Instead we drove right to the meeting at 80+ mph the whole way, no stops. When leaving the meeting, stopped at one of the hundreds of gas stations for 5 minutes and grabbed drinks for the ride home and make it home before dinner.

I don’t want to add stress and time to a trip like that in order to become an ambassador or missionary for the church of electric cars.

And even if I did, all it would do is prove to them we should have taken the Suburban.

The stress is probably even bigger than the time factor.

Know that feeling you get when you’re afraid you’re not going to make your airplane flight in time? I don’t like that feeling. The best thing that can happen is nothing goes wrong, it only goes downhill from there.

Just look at all the road-trip stories here. When someone makes it to a destination WITHOUT a problem…….it’s newsworthy!

I’ve spent time on car forums for over 20 years. This is the first one where people bragged about getting to a destination without having a refueling issue. ?
Sponsored

 
 







Top