Solar Panel Question

Arsenic17

Well-Known Member
First Name
Arsenic
Joined
Sep 23, 2022
Threads
10
Messages
314
Reaction score
257
Location
Denver, CO
Vehicles
MME GT 2023 Vapor Blue
Country flag
I am assuming you had a quote from an installer, not a lease company, but one that you have to buy outright? They are usually very honest, there may be state incentives that lower costs. We have 32 panels in Mass, we bought them at 2 separate times, 24panels in 2013 which had a full ROI in 4.25 years, then we added 8 more panels in 2018 with a 4 year ROI. When we first installed we had no kids, no central AC and no EV, so we thought we were future proofed with a 25% oversized system, but adding 2 kids, AC and EV we needed more!
What 4 years ROI? With that everyone in your entire state should have solar installed already. My system in CO will take 10-15 years to ROI. Electricity is pretty cheap (12 cents/kWh delivered).
Sponsored

 

JRB100

Well-Known Member
First Name
John
Joined
Mar 27, 2022
Threads
1
Messages
57
Reaction score
76
Location
Dallas
Vehicles
'22 Mustang Mach-e Select (C/T pkg) 10/10/22 build
Occupation
Retired educator
Country flag
When my 15kW system went live in 2019 my ROI was the typical 15-20 years. One month after the install, I switched out my single speed pool pump for a variable speed model cutting my monthly energy usage. My system generates 25%+ in excess. Bottom line, my ROI is now just over six years. It is important to get multiple quotes and pursue all incentives (or DIY if capable).
 

connoisseurr

Well-Known Member
First Name
Connor
Joined
Sep 29, 2021
Threads
35
Messages
1,394
Reaction score
1,624
Location
Northern VA
Vehicles
22 Rivian R1T, 23 Tesla MYP
Occupation
IT Engineering
Country flag
When my 15kW system went live in 2019 my ROI was the typical 15-20 years. One month after the install, I switched out my single speed pool pump for a variable speed model cutting my monthly energy usage. My system generates 25%+ in excess. Bottom line, my ROI is now just over six years. It is important to get multiple quotes and pursue all incentives (or DIY if capable).
It's crazy how much energy pool pumps use. Has always blown me away.

I noticed a big difference when I changed out my central air system. New home build in 2015, and the builder use an entry level Goodman 13 SEER AC + single speed gas furnace for heat. Replaced it with a 3T Daikin Fit 19 SEER dual fuel heat pump + natural gas emergency backup. My energy usage on the ventilation alone dropped 40%. The heat pump and gas furnace are modulating which uses as little energy as possible. HIGHLY recommend this system for anyone is need of a replacement. I had quotes from all the big players in the area: Trane, Carrier, Rheem, etc. The Daikin system cost was $12000, coming in $7k cheaper than the next lowest price option.

This type of system is great for solar as well. Super low energy inrush (doesn't kick on full blast, slowly ramps up to necessary speed).

Daikin also informed me they're working with Enphase to build an API connection between platforms, so if a home is equipped with any sort of energy backup solution, Enphase can adjust the Daikin system to run more efficiently, but raising/lowering the temperature call, thus reducing the overall energy requirement for air comfort. Huge win.
 

cryptk

Well-Known Member
First Name
Chris
Joined
Nov 15, 2022
Threads
2
Messages
128
Reaction score
129
Location
Texas
Vehicles
2023 Mach-E GTPE, Blazer EV RS (reserved)
Country flag
When my 15kW system went live in 2019 my ROI was the typical 15-20 years. One month after the install, I switched out my single speed pool pump for a variable speed model cutting my monthly energy usage. My system generates 25%+ in excess. Bottom line, my ROI is now just over six years. It is important to get multiple quotes and pursue all incentives (or DIY if capable).
You also hit on another thing, going Solar should be done as a holistic approach to energy usage at your home. I tend to recommend that people do Solar as a last (or near-last) step. At least knock out all of the easy stuff first: change incandescent bulbs to LED, maybe put some automatic/motion light switches in some places to reduce unnecessary energy usage, and (like you did) change out energy inefficient appliances to more energy efficient ones (if the original is nearing it's end of service life). You just happened to do that last bit (with the pool pump) after the solar install, but that was likely the better option as changing out an appliance just because the new one is more efficient has it's own ROI due to the up-front cost of purchasing the new appliance in the first place.
 

Scooby24

Well-Known Member
First Name
Greg
Joined
Jul 2, 2021
Threads
29
Messages
2,123
Reaction score
3,296
Location
Olathe, KS
Vehicles
'25 BMW i4 M50; '25 MME GT
Occupation
Healthcare IT
Country flag
solarwholesale.com

42 panels - 13.86kw system - 16k after tax credit. If you're handy, this is the way to go. If you're not...you can hire someone through them to which they suggest a 4-6k install cost on top. Comparative system from an installer was 3 times that cost.

1 panel is 330w at peak. average more like 250 on best day...for part of the day.

That's .25kw... it would take...weeks to charge your car on solar doing that. You need a lot more.
 


OP
OP

Shelbeast

Well-Known Member
First Name
RJ
Joined
Mar 16, 2022
Threads
13
Messages
276
Reaction score
128
Location
DMV (MD)
Vehicles
MME GT Delivered 9/9/22, GT500
Occupation
Sausage Maker
Country flag
You also hit on another thing, going Solar should be done as a holistic approach to energy usage at your home. I tend to recommend that people do Solar as a last (or near-last) step. At least knock out all of the easy stuff first: change incandescent bulbs to LED, maybe put some automatic/motion light switches in some places to reduce unnecessary energy usage, and (like you did) change out energy inefficient appliances to more energy efficient ones (if the original is nearing it's end of service life). You just happened to do that last bit (with the pool pump) after the solar install, but that was likely the better option as changing out an appliance just because the new one is more efficient has it's own ROI due to the up-front cost of purchasing the new appliance in the first place.
Damn! my girl has every socket filled with fresheners, night lights, better air filters, dog bowl waterfall, LED lights, its. Ugh!
 
OP
OP

Shelbeast

Well-Known Member
First Name
RJ
Joined
Mar 16, 2022
Threads
13
Messages
276
Reaction score
128
Location
DMV (MD)
Vehicles
MME GT Delivered 9/9/22, GT500
Occupation
Sausage Maker
Country flag
solarwholesale.com

42 panels - 13.86kw system - 16k after tax credit. If you're handy, this is the way to go. If you're not...you can hire someone through them to which they suggest a 4-6k install cost on top. Comparative system from an installer was 3 times that cost.

1 panel is 330w at peak. average more like 250 on best day...for part of the day.

That's .25kw... it would take...weeks to charge your car on solar doing that. You need a lot more.
Thanks! Great info.

Go Chiefs! LHS Class of 90.
 

MacherAWD

Well-Known Member
First Name
Erik
Joined
Mar 29, 2022
Threads
14
Messages
1,822
Reaction score
2,704
Location
North Shore MA
Vehicles
2021 AWD Select C&T, 2020 Bolt Premier
Occupation
Healthcare Software
Country flag
What 4 years ROI? With that everyone in your entire state should have solar installed already. My system in CO will take 10-15 years to ROI. Electricity is pretty cheap (12 cents/kWh delivered).
We have a strong SREC program here, so each Mega Watt I generate gets sold on an exchange (around $300) and I get a check tax free. I got 30% back in Taxes off initial, then between electric savings, we are full net metering, my meter spins both ways and I get credit for all over-production. Our rates are more expensive, we were paying 24 cents a kw for years, and now we pay over 30 cents a kw.

And I tell everyone to get solar if they can, we have a nice angled roof with perfect southern exposure and minimal trees on the back of our house, so we are ideal. I call the solar my part time job, been paying out an additional $2,500 a year after the initial ROI.
 

dtbaker61

Well-Known Member
First Name
Dan
Joined
May 11, 2020
Threads
126
Messages
4,822
Reaction score
4,524
Location
santa fe,nm
Website
www.envirokarma.org
Vehicles
MME (delivered 2/26/21), DIY eMiata BEV
Occupation
Solar Sales/install
Country flag
Has anyone had solar panel install just for your EV? Full home solar panel is still not a break even until 18 years (part gas). Not worth it. I am thinking of just getting one panel to connect to charging only. Has anyone did that? Any pros and cons? Thanks.

RJ
Since resi EV chargers are designed for 240vAC input.... you have to design/install a full 'grid-tied', or Hybrid Solar PV system which outputs 240vAC.

The amount of PV you want to install is enough to cover your household baseload, PLUS you expected daily consumption of the MME (1 kwhr / 3 miles driven daily), PLUS think about whether you might install mini-splits for heating/cooling and/or heat pump to heat water to reduce natural gas use in the near future.

The cost of Solar is typically a combination of some 'fixed project cost' for design, permitting, project management, interconnection paperwork, etc (around $2500) plus inverter(s), plus PV modules and install labor....

Do NOT buy the cheapest PV modules you can find. The warranties are crappy. Buy PV that has a true 25yr warranty; Hanwha Qcells, SilFab, Sunpower, Panasonic, and REC solar are a few good ones.... probably cost about $1/watt by the time you pay shipping, etc. Installed by professionals I would expect total cost to be about $3-4/watt PLUS $2500 for fixed project costs.

yes, you can do it yourself.... but by the time you figure out Permitting, and learn how to install, you should just hire professional authorized installers. In many states, if you DIY, you cannot get the State Tax Credits.... and with most mfg warranties, you will invalidate warranty if you are not licensed Electrician.


In most cases..... high quality PV is about 7% annual ROI on net investment.... pays for itself in about 11 years, and has a 25 year warranty.

cheap solar might be paid off a little quicker, but is out of warranty in 10 years.
 

Scooby24

Well-Known Member
First Name
Greg
Joined
Jul 2, 2021
Threads
29
Messages
2,123
Reaction score
3,296
Location
Olathe, KS
Vehicles
'25 BMW i4 M50; '25 MME GT
Occupation
Healthcare IT
Country flag
What 4 years ROI? With that everyone in your entire state should have solar installed already. My system in CO will take 10-15 years to ROI. Electricity is pretty cheap (12 cents/kWh delivered).
I'm at about 6 years ROI on my system and have 11 cents/kwh

Given I have 2 EVs and factoring in my relatively high usage as a result of two WFH jobs.

We drive about 1500 miles a month between both cars and around 2.5 mi/kwh that's roughly 600kwh a month from cars, and 2000 or so just in regular usage averaged out so over 2500kwh a month.

That would be an average bill of ~300 a month. Our actual average is ~100 a month. So roughly 2400 a year with 16k cost is a little over 6.5 years.

It's all about being smart and realizing people are over charging you for what you're getting and knowing how to do it for less, either DIY or partnering with an installer only that isn't looking to make a huge chunk of cash on sourcing the kit for you.
 

MachTee

Well-Known Member
First Name
Andy
Joined
Jun 9, 2021
Threads
5
Messages
368
Reaction score
574
Location
USA
Vehicles
MME Premium Infinite Blue SR AWD
Country flag
What 4 years ROI? With that everyone in your entire state should have solar installed already. My system in CO will take 10-15 years to ROI. Electricity is pretty cheap (12 cents/kWh delivered).
My system is also on track to reach ROI in 4yrs, as long as the sun keeps shining between now and July this year :) During the design phase, the projection to reach ROI was 4 years and 9 months, so it's a nice surprise to beat the projection.

Little refresher to myself to check my math. My system is a 12.21kW system, with 37 Panasonic panels running on Solar Edge inverter. Total system cost was $2.91 per watt. It came online in July 2019. As of right now it's generated 50MWh. So, ~$35K for the system, minus 30% from fed which was $10500, minus ~$11000 worth of SRECs, minus ~$7500 worth of electricity. So my "outstanding balance" is ~$6000 to reach ROI. Yes, ROI around summer this year seems about right. The funny thing with solar installer is that cash price gets you a lower system price than financing. Had I gone with financing, IIRC it would've been $3.25 per watt for the same system.

This is highly dependent on the state you live in of course. I'm in NJ. People love to poke fun at NJ, but it's a great state to live in for installer a solar system and buying EVs.
 

ab13

Well-Known Member
Joined
Feb 17, 2020
Threads
3
Messages
584
Reaction score
470
Location
California
Vehicles
Rav4 Hybrid
Country flag
You should check on the incentives in your area. Aside from the Federal 30% tax credit some places like New York state have pretty big incentives. You also have to check Net Metering rules of the electric company, basically how much they pay you for solar you generate.

In Southern California, about 6-8 panels (400W) would be needed for powering a car for a year, about 4000+ kWh.
 

engnrng

Well-Known Member
First Name
Bruce
Joined
Feb 8, 2020
Threads
9
Messages
579
Reaction score
826
Location
SoCal
Vehicles
2022 GTPE, Kona EV, 2023 BMW iX
Occupation
Engineer
Country flag
Has anyone had solar panel install just for your EV? Full home solar panel is still not a break even until 18 years (part gas). Not worth it. I am thinking of just getting one panel to connect to charging only. Has anyone did that? Any pros and cons? Thanks.

RJ
Couple of things because I am an engineer. First, the power of a solar system is expressed in units of kW. The energy of an energy storage system is kWh. Your utility charges you for the kWh used. I have a 14 kW (peak) solar array (SoCal) and 40 kWh battery storage - pretty big system for our over 4000 sf house with pool pump and 2 EVs. ROI means Return on Investment and is expressed in terms of % annual return on $$ investment. Pay Back is expressed in Years or Months. As I was taught in school, ROI can be expressed as either a straight cash savings based on initial $$ invested, or as after-tax savings. In the case of solar, the savings is directly related to the bills you no longer pay the utility company and is tax-free, as long as you own the panels. My personal ROI started at 6% Tax Free, but has been increasing the last couple of years because the utility rates that I don't pay have been increasing. I don't care what Pay Back time period is, I do care that almost 8% Tax Free Rate of Return on my investment is pretty darn good and I am very happy. My solar storage takes me through the expensive evening hours and I charge my cars between 10 pm and 4 pm the next day, because that is when the utility rates are lowest. My storage batteries are usually charged up by noon, so the afternoon excess solar generation goes to the grid. I pay $.28 per kWh when I buy it from the grid and the utility pays me $0.04 per kWh when I send excess generation to the grid. Fortunately, I am on Net Energy Metering, so the settlement is supposedly calculated on an annual basis. As long as I generate more kWh each year than I use, my annual settlement is minimal or zero. I am now replacing my gas furnace with a heat pump, so I anticipate a settlement at the end of the year because I am using more kWh, but my gas bill tripled last month, so I still come out ahead with the heat pump.

These numbers for my system are based on paying a solar installation contractor. If you DIY as suggested in one post, your ROI will be much higher (higher is good!) and your Pay Back time will be far shorter.
 

Arsenic17

Well-Known Member
First Name
Arsenic
Joined
Sep 23, 2022
Threads
10
Messages
314
Reaction score
257
Location
Denver, CO
Vehicles
MME GT 2023 Vapor Blue
Country flag
My system is also on track to reach ROI in 4yrs, as long as the sun keeps shining between now and July this year :) During the design phase, the projection to reach ROI was 4 years and 9 months, so it's a nice surprise to beat the projection.

Little refresher to myself to check my math. My system is a 12.21kW system, with 37 Panasonic panels running on Solar Edge inverter. Total system cost was $2.91 per watt. It came online in July 2019. As of right now it's generated 50MWh. So, ~$35K for the system, minus 30% from fed which was $10500, minus ~$11000 worth of SRECs, minus ~$7500 worth of electricity. So my "outstanding balance" is ~$6000 to reach ROI. Yes, ROI around summer this year seems about right. The funny thing with solar installer is that cash price gets you a lower system price than financing. Had I gone with financing, IIRC it would've been $3.25 per watt for the same system.

This is highly dependent on the state you live in of course. I'm in NJ. People love to poke fun at NJ, but it's a great state to live in for installer a solar system and buying EVs.
Wow Northeast states really incentivize solar --- the probably have to considering how cloudy it is. Plus also if you are a big energy consumer with a huge system you can lessen the hit from the flat installation fees for permits, planning and design, etc.

Here are my CO numbers:

21 panels at 325W = ~6.8kW system
$19000 panel cost - 26% tax credit in 2020 = ~$14,000 ($2.05/W)
Annual electric usage is 8400 kWh at ~14 cents/kWh = ~$1200
ROI = $14000 / $1200 = ~12 years
 

engnrng

Well-Known Member
First Name
Bruce
Joined
Feb 8, 2020
Threads
9
Messages
579
Reaction score
826
Location
SoCal
Vehicles
2022 GTPE, Kona EV, 2023 BMW iX
Occupation
Engineer
Country flag
Wow Northeast states really incentivize solar --- the probably have to considering how cloudy it is. Plus also if you are a big energy consumer with a huge system you can lessen the hit from the flat installation fees for permits, planning and design, etc.

Here are my CO numbers:

21 panels at 325W = ~6.8kW system
$19000 panel cost - 26% tax credit in 2020 = ~$14,000 ($2.05/W)
Annual electric usage is 8400 kWh at ~14 cents/kWh = ~$1200
ROI = $14000 / $1200 = ~12 years
Your Pay Back Period is 12 years. What do you calculate your ROI (% Return on Investment)?
Sponsored

 
 







Top