locks66
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- Sep 17, 2021
- Threads
- 32
- Messages
- 256
- Reaction score
- 259
- Location
- Minneapolis
- Vehicles
- 2021 Mach E GT
- Thread starter
- #46
Holy crap. That's an amazing story. Yeah I plan to try and push on USAA. I just replaced my 12v. Replaced my summers and winters. And kept my car immaculate minus small rock chips. This is helpful.having just gone through this (rear ended, car totalled), i feel for you. i had thought my 21 job 1 premium rwd std would be repaired and was looking into some reimbursement for value reduction but it ended up being totalled. so i agree with the others, i think yours will be given it looks significantly worse than mine. number one is physical safety/recovery so yes, hope your wife is doing ok.
but after that, definitely the hassle of being without the car you know and love (although hopefully you have rental coverage or if not, the other guy's insurance should pay for a rental).
and then there's getting a decent market value compensation. but even when it is reasonable, it's still not the exact car you had, right? like i had already dealt with all the recalls, hvbjb, etc. and had just put on aftermarket eibach springs/swaybars, upgraded rims, blue cruise extension, extended warranty, etc, all of which usually is not taken into account or reimbursed (unless you purchase some additional insurance rider).
what i would say is, for sure feel free to give a little bit of pushback if the number the total claims adjuster comes in with feels on the low end.
for my 21 premium std @ 60k miles, i initially got a fairly reasonable $28k (considering i bought it for $39k). i did my own comps since i honestly loved the car and wanted to be back in the same car (or maybe a extended battery one) and their number was on the high end for my area (LA). but i knew i would still have to fork over money out of pocket to get the replacement car up to where i had the old car. so i mentioned that and even sent him receipts. while he couldn't comp or reimburse me for those, he asked me a weird question: "what number would make you happy?" this is AAA btw, which we've been with forever and also covers our home insurance (don't know for sure how much of that plays a role in this story).
i didn't really have a number immediately off hand, since i didn't expect to be asked! in retrospect, probably $30k for a prorated comp for for all that other stuff.
he looked at the photos the adjuster had taken and said "looks like you kept your car in really good shape" and then said "let me work on this." a few hours later came back with $35k. while i know KBB has the fair/good/excellent/etc scoring system and value adjusts for that, i definitely didn't expect that big of a bump. and maybe they went after the other company's insurance so that allowed them come back with a higher number, who knows.
but that's what allowed me to replace the 21 premium with a 23 gt pe, which is better in every way. so sometimes things work out![]()
I have a Sentra from my insurance company, I always keep rental coverage on, right now it seems like I'm going to look at a used ev9. We needed to upsize as it was but I had planned two years from now. Hopefully I can get them over the value of my loan and that extra 20% replacement coverage I have pays off in a big way
Sponsored