Indy Mike
Well-Known Member
- First Name
- Mike
- Joined
- May 10, 2021
- Threads
- 29
- Messages
- 168
- Reaction score
- 35
- Location
- Indiana
- Vehicles
- Mach E Prem AWD, 2019 F150, ‘94 Vet, 1948 Willys
- Occupation
- Retired
Thanks for sharing that. Leaving kids and dogs in an unlocked car for a very brief time, not a good idea. A wife and 91 year old father-in-law, I’m ok with that. I guess I’ll have to take our 4# Yorkie into the store with me. She will not be a happy dog if she doesn’t get to ride along. But seriously, thanks for sharing. At least we now know why.I hope at least a few others with similar frustrations find this helpful. I had a call with a Ford engineer today, and he explained why I cannot keep the interior motion sensors turned off.
TL/DR: It is NOT a bug. Just poor design. But maybe a design that will be improved in the future.
First, the issue: my kids or dog frequently set off the car alarm when they get into the car before I do, or if I step out of the car to run into the store, commence a public charge, etc. You can temporarily avoid that by enabling “ask on exit” to manually deactivate the sensors every time you turn off the car [update: apparently even this doesn’t work consistently according to posts below] but that’s a little annoying. So I had hoped to permanently disable the motion sensors in the menu. Under Setting > Vehicle > Alarm you can turn Motion Sensors On or Off. But if you toggle them to Off, they still revert back to On each time you restart the car.
I thought this was a bug. It is not. It is just poor design. Or, to be more specific, old design that doesn’t take into account newer functionality. Here’s what I mean….
When the engineer took my issue back to the team, they didn’t understand what I was doing. They said (paraphrasing): “Why is this an issue? The motion sensors are only active when the car is locked. So how are people getting into the car before him? And why is he locking kids / pets in the car?”
Ok, put aside that sometimes you might want to lock your kids / pets in the car - the engineer explained that my issue is PAAK and the “walk away lock” feature. The car unlocks when I’m close by, allowing my kids to get in, and locks when I walk away, with my kids still in the car. And then the alarm activates. The motion sensors were not designed to be permanently disabled because, back before PAAK and the “walk away lock” functionality, it wasn’t nearly as much of an issue.
He said the solution was to disable the “walk away lock” feature, and either don’t lock the car when kids or pets are inside, or manually disable the sensors each time I do leave them inside.
Ok. So first I agreed with the engineer on his diagnosis and conceded that this was deliberate design and not a bug. But I then explained that it is poor design for several reasons:
So I suggested a couple of future functionalities to resolve the issue:
- It’s confusing. If you cannot permanently disable the motion sensors, why even include that toggle 5 taps deep into the menu? Nobody wants to go that deep into the menu every time (and I understand you don’t have to if you enable “ask on exit” but that doesn’t eliminate the confusion of the motion sensor toggle deep in the menus).
- There are rare instances where you will want to lock kids / pets briefly inside the car.
- The “ask on exit” is not a suitable workaround because it is cumbersome having to engage with that every time you turn off your car.
- If your car is locked with the windows down, such as possibly in the garage, you can easily set off the motion sensors just by walking too closely to the car.
- Disabling “walk away lock” is not a viable workaround because that is a very useful feature (most of the time)!
He agreed with my points, and seemed particularly enthused about the safe zone solution.
- Allow the motion sensors to be permanently disabled, and/or
- Allow “safe zones” to be set, such as a home garage, where walk away lock does not trigger (this is a feature already included in the Super Poll).
So good news and bad news. Bad news is this isn’t a bug that will be fixed anytime soon. Good news is that I’m guessing we’ll eventually get a good workaround with a future enhancement of adding safe zones.
Sponsored