Jimrpa

Well-Known Member
First Name
Jim
Joined
Sep 10, 2020
Threads
297
Messages
9,521
Reaction score
12,854
Location
Wayne, PA
Vehicles
2021 Infinite Blue Premium Mustang Mach E ER AWD
Occupation
Retied (formerly tried to herd highly technical, independent cats)
Country flag
They can spend years and likely millions creating an extremely complicated and over-engineered heat pump but they can’t figure a way to keep a usable frunk. Yeah.
Basically, what I’ve been ranting about all along. The sad thing is that we are likely going to have to wait for “out of spec blowhard” to publish one of his epic 4 hour videos, rambling on about the back roads of the Rockies to get any kind of info on the “performance” of the heat pump, and by then, it will be the middle of July! ???
Sponsored

 

Peugfan

Well-Known Member
Joined
Jan 26, 2021
Threads
1
Messages
218
Reaction score
230
Location
Minnesota
Vehicles
2017 Linc MKX, 2021 MME Prem 4EX Infinite Blue
Country flag
Didn’t Musk offer up his (supposedly) much simpler ‘OCTO-VALVE’ heat pump design to the world for anyone to use? This certainly doesn’t look like Ford made much, if any, use of that design……..
[/QUOTE]
So you think an OCTO-VALVE with 20+(don't remember exact number) operating modes is simpler than a five way (PENTA VALVE) system LOLOLOL.
 

RWG

Well-Known Member
First Name
Randal
Joined
Jan 16, 2022
Threads
0
Messages
169
Reaction score
231
Location
Chaska Minnesota
Vehicles
2021 Mach E
Occupation
Retired
Country flag
As a former, now retired, refrigeration tech and Product Manager, I agree with many of the comments. Heat pumps are complicated and technical problems will most likely baffle many techs. However I think I understand the Product Management/Engineering motivation.

EV batter Range is a big issue. Here in Minnesota, last week when temps were subzero, when I looked at the trip app. on my 2021 MACH E there were times when as much as 40% of my battery power was allegedly used to heat the cabin and batteries. That severally reduced our battery mileage range but it was no big deal because we only made short trips around town. Heat Pumps are theoretically more efficient than electric heaters so everyone is jumping on the "heat pump technology bandwagon" in an effort to improve EV range. Years ago a household heat pump was not very efficient when the ambients dropped to the 30's and 40's. So when trying to heat your house with a heat pump at those temps. it was not the most cost efficient. i.e you were better off just heating with electricity. But science and engineering has advanced and now heat pumps are much better/efficient at lower ambient temps. However, they are complicated and like any new technology there will be a reliability learning curve. It will probably take a while to workout the issues. All of us, who worked in the refrigeration & AC community knew the the more complicated a system was lead to new reliability and repair challenges. I suspect it will be the same with heat pumps in cars but heat pump technology is not new but it is evolving, fast.


The basic operational theory of a Heat Pump is it can extract the heat from the ambient air and put it in your vehicle more efficiently than running electric heaters which put out 3.41 btus per watt. At higher ambients, heat pumps can be more than 200 times more efficient, or as an example, 1 watt of expended electrical energy to run a heat pump could, theoretically give you over 600 btus of heat. The issue is, a cubic ft of 50degree ambient air has a lot more heat in it than a cubic foot of 0 degree air. Therefore, as the ambient temp drops, so does the efficiency of a heat pump and based of system design and efficiency there is a point of "diminishing returns", i.e. you are better off just heating with a resistance heater vs. a heat pump.

I suspect, "gone are they days" when you could pick up a can of refrigerant at your local auto parts store, and recharge your own automotive AC system. These new Heat Pump/AC systems require specialized training and equipment for repairs and a good tech it will be a combination of good old mechanical/refrigeration skills and digital electronics. I am sure these new systems use CPU's in order to get the maximum system efficiency. Therefore heat pumps will add more CPU & Software tech to the vehicle and it will take a while for the technical community to catch up. However, up here in Minnesota, when we have subzero ambient temps I don't know if heat pumps will make much of a difference , but they definitely will on a 50 degree day.
 

grein002

Well-Known Member
First Name
Scott
Joined
Mar 5, 2024
Threads
9
Messages
266
Reaction score
409
Location
Durham, NC
Vehicles
2023 Mach-E GTPE, Red w/Gray interior
Country flag
Replying to Peugfan's post "So you think an OCTO-VALVE with 20+(don't remember exact number) operating modes is simpler than a five way (PENTA VALVE) system LOLOLOL."

So, heat pumps in general are pretty simple, not much different than AC-only units. However, designing for very low temps in a vehicle requires multiple operating modes and a lot of valves / plumbing. The purpose of the octovalve is to simplify implementation of a complex multi-mode heat pump from a plumbing and packaging perspective, not to make it a simple single-mode heat pump.
 

jdeve

Well-Known Member
First Name
John
Joined
Dec 26, 2023
Threads
1
Messages
159
Reaction score
70
Location
Kentucky
Vehicles
2023 MME GT performance edition rapid red metallic
Occupation
retired back to work IT guy
Country flag
I have never used my frunk in my first year of ownership.
 


mkhuffman

Well-Known Member
First Name
Mike
Joined
Nov 19, 2020
Threads
29
Messages
6,875
Reaction score
9,507
Location
Virginia
Vehicles
2025 Rivian R1T Tri-Max, Jeep GC-L, VW Jetta
Country flag
I have never used my frunk in my first year of ownership.
You need to get Chinese take-out more often.

Basically, what I’ve been ranting about all along. The sad thing is that we are likely going to have to wait for “out of spec blowhard” to publish one of his epic 4 hour videos, rambling on about the back roads of the Rockies to get any kind of info on the “performance” of the heat pump, and by then, it will be the middle of July! ???
Sandy can fix it.
 

Doobster6

Well-Known Member
First Name
Len
Joined
Aug 1, 2024
Threads
19
Messages
225
Reaction score
278
Location
Exton, PA
Vehicles
2024 Mach-E Premium extended battery, Vapor Blue
Occupation
Retired manufacturing executive
Country flag
I have never used my frunk in my first year of ownership.
I used mine once, in the first month of ownership, just because I could. But I could just have easily put the same stuff in the back with the seats folded. Nevertheless, I consider a frunk a nice thing to have JIC, and I agree with others here who suggest that better engineering, perhaps leveraging the octovalve system, might have saved the frunk from shrinking.
 

SpeedRacer72

Well-Known Member
Joined
Feb 16, 2022
Threads
9
Messages
166
Reaction score
274
Location
California
Vehicles
2018 Mustang, 2024 Tesla Model Y Performance
Country flag
The dual 5-way coolant valves would be the functional equivalent of the Tesla Octavalve. With the heat pump, both systems would now have similar functionality as a whole.
You seem to know a lot about the MME.
What is the purpose of the shutters on the front?
I hit a jackrabbit with my MME a few years ago and it busted the shutter, it was $8,000 in repairs.
 

SanCarlosJeff

Member
First Name
Jeff
Joined
Sep 28, 2024
Threads
0
Messages
15
Reaction score
12
Location
Northern California
Vehicles
2024 Mach-E Premium, 2024 Ioniq 5
You seem to know a lot about the MME.
What is the purpose of the shutters on the front?
I hit a jackrabbit with my MME a few years ago and it busted the shutter, it was $8,000 in repairs.
Active shutters are on a lot of cars to allow for better aerodymics at speed. They are probably there to help cool the battery in high temp situations on the MME.
 

RWG

Well-Known Member
First Name
Randal
Joined
Jan 16, 2022
Threads
0
Messages
169
Reaction score
231
Location
Chaska Minnesota
Vehicles
2021 Mach E
Occupation
Retired
Country flag
I experienced the same surprise, the wind forced a construction cone in my path, I was traveling at low speed, it was a construction zone, as such I "bumped the orange cone,"when I got it home I found the proximity sensor was damaged, as well as the shutters. The repairs were a few thousand dollars. I was told the shutters open and close to help manage AC performance and cool the batteries when needed. Those plastic components are fragile and expensive.
 

bbulkow

Well-Known Member
First Name
Brian
Joined
Aug 30, 2022
Threads
24
Messages
889
Reaction score
729
Location
menlo park, california
Vehicles
Honda CRV
Country flag
As a former, now retired, refrigeration tech and Product Manager, I agree with many of the comments. Heat pumps are complicated and technical problems will most likely baffle many techs. However I think I understand the Product Management/Engineering motivation.

EV batter Range is a big issue. Here in Minnesota, last week when temps were subzero, when I looked at the trip app. on my 2021 MACH E there were times when as much as 40% of my battery power was allegedly used to heat the cabin and batteries. That severally reduced our battery mileage range but it was no big deal because we only made short trips around town. Heat Pumps are theoretically more efficient than electric heaters so everyone is jumping on the "heat pump technology bandwagon" in an effort to improve EV range. Years ago a household heat pump was not very efficient when the ambients dropped to the 30's and 40's. So when trying to heat your house with a heat pump at those temps. it was not the most cost efficient. i.e you were better off just heating with electricity. But science and engineering has advanced and now heat pumps are much better/efficient at lower ambient temps. However, they are complicated and like any new technology there will be a reliability learning curve. It will probably take a while to workout the issues. All of us, who worked in the refrigeration & AC community knew the the more complicated a system was lead to new reliability and repair challenges. I suspect it will be the same with heat pumps in cars but heat pump technology is not new but it is evolving, fast.


The basic operational theory of a Heat Pump is it can extract the heat from the ambient air and put it in your vehicle more efficiently than running electric heaters which put out 3.41 btus per watt. At higher ambients, heat pumps can be more than 200 times more efficient, or as an example, 1 watt of expended electrical energy to run a heat pump could, theoretically give you over 600 btus of heat. The issue is, a cubic ft of 50degree ambient air has a lot more heat in it than a cubic foot of 0 degree air. Therefore, as the ambient temp drops, so does the efficiency of a heat pump and based of system design and efficiency there is a point of "diminishing returns", i.e. you are better off just heating with a resistance heater vs. a heat pump.

I suspect, "gone are they days" when you could pick up a can of refrigerant at your local auto parts store, and recharge your own automotive AC system. These new Heat Pump/AC systems require specialized training and equipment for repairs and a good tech it will be a combination of good old mechanical/refrigeration skills and digital electronics. I am sure these new systems use CPU's in order to get the maximum system efficiency. Therefore heat pumps will add more CPU & Software tech to the vehicle and it will take a while for the technical community to catch up. However, up here in Minnesota, when we have subzero ambient temps I don't know if heat pumps will make much of a difference , but they definitely will on a 50 degree day.
Here here.

I notice that 15% of my battery range goes to climate. I'm not crazy about it. And I drive in California and I don't think ever below 30F.

I spent a lot of money to buy a battery that was about 15% larger. And heavier.

The "mechanical complexity" is low. It's valves.

The complexity of debugging a failure in the system is high - but valves throw error codes when they stick. Code is thrown, tech replaces valve. That's about all you can expect these days. There's no "shade tree" "heck, look at that ding in that there coolant pipe, that's in the fourth phase of the anti-compressor, just like I suspected - let's pull that ding out and get you back on the road"

It does look REALLY complicated. But that's what engineering companies are supposed to be doing.

I'm sure they'll make it simpler the rev after.
 
OP
OP
Mach-Lee

Mach-Lee

Well-Known Member
First Name
Lee
Joined
Jul 16, 2021
Threads
262
Messages
11,344
Reaction score
24,965
Location
Wisconsin
Vehicles
2022 Mach-E Premium AWD
Occupation
Sci/Eng
Country flag
You seem to know a lot about the MME.
What is the purpose of the shutters on the front?
I hit a jackrabbit with my MME a few years ago and it busted the shutter, it was $8,000 in repairs.
The active grille shutters are there to help reduce drag. Having them closed makes the car more aerodynamic. They will only open when cooling is needed, and can adjust anywhere from 0 to 100% open. Ford has used this technology on their other cars for about the past 10 years to improve fuel economy.
 

motto

Member
First Name
Matthias
Joined
Dec 31, 2024
Threads
2
Messages
17
Reaction score
13
Location
Edmonton, AB, Canada
Vehicles
2021 MME Premium ER AWD
Looking forward to seeing performance numbers at various temps. That will allow anyone to determine if it will make a meaningful impact for their specific climate.

As for reliability/maintenance: Time will tell for this particular implementation of a Heat pump system. Overall this tech isn't that radically new and Ford is not trail-blazing but following the industry trend.
 

SpeedRacer72

Well-Known Member
Joined
Feb 16, 2022
Threads
9
Messages
166
Reaction score
274
Location
California
Vehicles
2018 Mustang, 2024 Tesla Model Y Performance
Country flag
The active grille shutters are there to help reduce drag. Having them closed makes the car more aerodynamic. They will only open when cooling is needed, and can adjust anywhere from 0 to 100% open. Ford has used this technology on their other cars for about the past 10 years to improve fuel economy.
Interesting. Thanks.
 
 







Top